Post by Drifter on Feb 14, 2015 7:41:03 GMT
Bird with a Broken Wing (Crowd Source)
Please donate towards the production of "Bird with a Broken Wing" by clicking the link below.
Also, don't forget to share with family, friends, other web boards, etc. Thank you!
80 Replies
5041 Views
Flag
Add feed to My Home
View Feed
I Know That Your Heart Is In The Right Place
However, based on your the vibe from your poster and the previous movies you have made, I don't think you are the right guy to make this film. I find your work to be distasteful and insensitive. Maybe there is a reason why different groups have expressed similar concerns to you. Maybe you should take a break and try and hear what they are saying.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by Repoman, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts
I Know That Your Heart Is In The Right Place
However, based on your the vibe from your poster and the previous movies you have made, I don't think you are the right guy to make this film. I find your work to be distasteful and insensitive. Maybe there is a reason why different groups have expressed similar concerns to you. Maybe you should take a break and try and hear what they are saying.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by Repoman, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts
Here's An Example
ablogofhorror.com/a-real-life-horror-tale-an-interview-with-filmmaker-cameron-cloutier/
You want me to donate to this kind of crap? You must be out of your * mind.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by Repoman, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts
Repoman
Think all you want that I'm not the right guy to make this film, but Janelle's family, as well as many others, do. That is what counts.
Maybe if you actually read the interview I gave in that link, you'd feel differently.
That being said, because this story has true aspects of horror to it (whether you want to admit it or not), the horror film community is interested in the creation of this film.
I would be a fool not to take them up on their offer to do an interview or have a story written about it. You do realize that the making of this film has played a role in getting this case more exposure, right?
Keep in mind, the movie I am making is not a horror film--but one that has horror in it. How can it not?
I don't expect you to donate, Repoman. I didn't post the link for you. I did it so the people who do support me, who read this board, can find me to support this project--if not in financing, then in spreading the word.
And before you pollute this thread any longer with your warped misunderstandings (and filthy words), keep in mind that the film was mentioned on ABC the other night.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by MovieMan, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By MovieMan
Member
3 months ago
297 Posts
Re: Bird with a Broken Wing (Crowd Source)
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by MovieMan, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By MovieMan
Member
3 months ago
297 Posts
Re: Repoman
Posted By: MovieMan
Think all you want that I'm not the right guy to make this film, but Janelle's family, as well as many others, do. That is what counts.
Maybe if you actually read the interview I gave in that link, you'd feel differently.
That being said, because this story has true aspects of horror to it (whether you want to admit it or not), the horror film community is interested in the creation of this film.
I would be a fool not to take them up on their offer to do an interview or have a story written about it. You do realize that the making of this film has played a role in getting this case more exposure, right?
Keep in mind, the movie I am making is not a horror film--but one that has horror in it. How can it not?
I don't expect you to donate, Repoman. I didn't post the link for you. I did it so the people who do support me, who read this board, can find me to support this project--if not in financing, then in spreading the word.
And before you pollute this thread any longer with your warped misunderstandings (and filthy words), keep in mind that the film was mentioned on ABC the other night.
I deeply apologize that my filthy words have offended you. The world doesn't need another horror movie. I don't give a rats ass if they mentioned your film on TV. Half of what is on TV is pure crap. I know that your heart is in the right place. I just think that your brain has been marinating in horror films for so long that you can't even see why the tone of your poster is distasteful. Or why the fact that you see to be obsessed with horror films might be a concern to me and others. Or the fact that all the websites that you have been interviewed on are dripping in blood horror film sites might be offensive. If you want to make a documentary with horror in it. Then go ahead. It is a free country and I strongly believe in free speech. Why don't you work a couple of extra jobs for a year or two save up some money and then go make what ever kind of movie you feel like. I just can't take the nerve of your entitlement generation having the gall to come around asking for others to pay for your misguided hobbies. And I did read the interview. In fact I have read every interview that has been linked here. Why should the people of this board give you $800,000 to make a film? Wouldn't we be better off spending our money in other ways to promote this case?
Flag
Quote
Quote
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts
Re: Repoman
Posted By: MovieMan
Think all you want that I'm not the right guy to make this film, but Janelle's family, as well as many others, do. That is what counts.
Maybe if you actually read the interview I gave in that link, you'd feel differently.
That being said, because this story has true aspects of horror to it (whether you want to admit it or not), the horror film community is interested in the creation of this film.
I would be a fool not to take them up on their offer to do an interview or have a story written about it. You do realize that the making of this film has played a role in getting this case more exposure, right?
Keep in mind, the movie I am making is not a horror film--but one that has horror in it. How can it not?
I don't expect you to donate, Repoman. I didn't post the link for you. I did it so the people who do support me, who read this board, can find me to support this project--if not in financing, then in spreading the word.
And before you pollute this thread any longer with your warped misunderstandings (and filthy words), keep in mind that the film was mentioned on ABC the other night.
I deeply apologize that my filthy words have offended you. The world doesn't need another horror movie. I don't give a rats ass if they mentioned your film on TV. Half of what is on TV is pure crap. I know that your heart is in the right place. I just think that your brain has been marinating in horror films for so long that you can't even see why the tone of your poster is distasteful. Or why the fact that you see to be obsessed with horror films might be a concern to me and others. Or the fact that all the websites that you have been interviewed on are dripping in blood horror film sites might be offensive. If you want to make a documentary with horror in it. Then go ahead. It is a free country and I strongly believe in free speech. Why don't you work a couple of extra jobs for a year or two save up some money and then go make what ever kind of movie you feel like. I just can't take the nerve of your entitlement generation having the gall to come around asking for others to pay for your misguided hobbies. And I did read the interview. In fact I have read every interview that has been linked here. Why should the people of this board give you $800,000 to make a film? Wouldn't we be better off spending our money in other ways to promote this case?
Flag
Quote
Quote
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts
grants
Movieman- Have you sourced any grants? There are sometimes great funding opportunities from private organizations? The horror of this story doesn't originate with gore for me. It is a story so primal that the horror is generated by the normal sounds of the night- a furnace clicking on, a dog's bark, a pine cone falling on a rooftop. I'm not an artist, but I have always visualized a movie about this case opening with a pan of a nightstand with a detectives badge and gun on it, sleeping man and woman in bed and then the click of a thermostat in a hallway -then the man's eyes open immediately, he sits upright and reaches for the gun. That is the true horror of this story- the ordinariness of life suddenly transformed into terror by this monster- whether he was there or not.
www.tribecafilminstitute.org/filmmakers/tfi_documentary/about/
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by PortofLeith, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By PortofLeith
Member
3 months ago
950 Posts
Re: grants
Posted By: PortofLeith
Movieman- Have you sourced any grants? There are sometimes great funding opportunities from private organizations>
www.tribecafilminstitute.org/filmmakers/tfi_documentary/about/
Yeah. Go ask them.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by Repoman, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts
$242
I see that you are up to $242. I have to ask how much are you pitching in? If you believe in this project then why don't you leverage everything that you have and make it? At least then you can say I sold everything that I own and I just need some folks to donate and match what I'm throwing in myself. You do that and I might even contribute. Right now you just like the guy in front of the grocery store with his hand out. You can't ask others to believe in your film more than you do.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts
My entitlement generation?
Repoman writes: I deeply apologize that my filthy words have offended you.
I say: You should be.
Repoman writes: The world doesn't need another horror movie.
I say: You're right. Again, my film is not a horror movie. It's not a documentary either. It's a feature film.
Repoman writes: I just think that your brain has been marinating in horror films for so long that you can't even see why the tone of your poster is distasteful.
I say: Funny, that poster shows in one image what the film is going to be about. Distasteful? The poster is clearly pro Janelle and her family is happy with it.
Repoman writes: Or why the fact that you see to be obsessed with horror films might be a concern to me and others. Or the fact that all the websites that you have been interviewed on are dripping in blood horror film sites might be offensive.
I say: I am not obsessed with horror films. I barely watch them. Also, I am not responsible for what websites do with their backgrounds. If someone in the media wants to talk with me about the film, and it gets the cases more attention, I will.
Repoman writes: Why don't you work a couple of extra jobs for a year or two save up some money and then go make what ever kind of movie you feel like. I just can't take the nerve of your entitlement generation having the gall to come around asking for others to pay for your misguided hobbies.
I say: Welcome to the 21st century. I do have money of my own set aside for the film, but a real movie costs more than what an independent filmmaker has. That's where crowdsourcing, or fundraising comes in. You don't have to like it, but millions of people, of all ages, do it now. It helps people know a project, or whatever it is you're raising money for, needs support.
As for me, being entitled... you're insane. I work my tail off, full time, then come home and work another 14 or so hours. I am not part of the me generation. Infact, I've spent the last four years of my life trying to get Janelle, and the other victim's stories, out there.
Repoman writes: Why should the people of this board give you $800,000 to make a film? Wouldn't we be better off spending our money in other ways to promote this case?
I say: Not asking them too. But maybe someone knows someone who would be willing to throw in a dollar. That's how crowd sourcing works, my friend. You have to let people know a project exists.
That being said, a real feature film made about this subject would open the floodgates and get EVERYONE talking about these cases--and not just true crime buffs.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Profile Image
By MovieMan
Member
3 months ago
297 Posts
You Don't Watch Horror Films?
"I am not obsessed with horror films. I barely watch them."
Cameron I deeply apologize for my filthy language and for accussing you of being really into horror films. I think what happened is that I confused you with a different guy (with the same exact name) also from Monteray that is really into Clockwork Orange, Hannibal etc. Now that I know that you are not that guy. I apologize. That Cameron seems to really be into these kinds of films. In fact he spends a lot of time writing reviews where he compares these films at length. Again I apologize for confusing you guys.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts
Re: Bird with a Broken Wing (Crowd Source)
I strongly disagree with Repoman in this thread.
As someone who has published some seven hundred movie reviews at IMDb and written a screenplay myself, I can tell Repoman there is a difference between MovieMan's film and a horror story. That difference is ... genre.
A horror story is a work of fiction. The films by Dario Argento are rightly designated as "horror" films; they are all fiction.
"Bird With A Broken Wing" will not be a fictional story ... at least if the script doesn't veer too far from the facts as we know them.
The correct genre for MovieMan's film would be either film documentary, or drama, or thriller, or bio, possibly a combo of all four.
Where MovieMan gets his money is irrelevant. If horror fans want to contribute $ to MovieMan's project ... fine and dandy. Repoman, you must keep in mind the difficulty of making a film ... any film.
Hollywood studios routinely invest milliions of dollars on a film's production; and the result ... the movie bombs! But those studios have deep, deep pockets. They can afford to make flops. An individual cannot. The business of indie film production is daunting! For every indie film that gets released, there are hundreds or thousands that don't.
For these reasons, and for the publicity that "Bird With A Broken Wing" can generate for this criminal case, I'm more than willing to watch "Bird With A Broken Wing" and give it a positive recommendation at IMDb if it even remotely measures up to my standards. I have done that for other indie producers.
I think Repoman has gotten hung-up on the word "horror", and mistakingly assumed that "Bird With A Broken Wing" will be ... just another silly horror film directed at a juvenile audience.
Edit
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by Drifter, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By Drifter
Member
3 months ago
371 Posts
Janelle Cruz Documentary
MM,
If I may chime in here, I have mentioned this to you before, so I will take the opportunity to mention it again. I would like to see a feature-length documentary on Janelle Cruz. Not only would it help the case, it might help with the financing for your proposed film. The shortcomings with the docs on the EAR/ONS case is that they were limited by the TV format. The longest doc was the THS Investigates at an hour long. Subtract from that the commercials and it's actual runtime was 45 minutes or less.
45 minutes (or less) dedicated to a case which spanned (at the time) 33 years. There just is not enough time to do the case any justice, as good as those docs were. Even the film "Zodiac" cut out some of the crimes as well as letters/ciphers and the film's runtime was 158 minutes. BTW, Zodiac had an excellent documentary as an extra on the DVD/Blu Ray.
2 hours dedicated to Janelle Cruz' life is possible. I think she was shortchanged anyway. Her death received scant news coverage back in 1986. Same with Manuela Witthuhn. The documentary could follow two tracks -- Janelle's path from birth to 18 years old and the EAR/ONS path from Sacramento to Irvine and finally where the two paths inexorably crossed.
So far, the most powerful and moving footage about Janelle came from you interviewing her mother and her recounting the "white dress" story. Let me know if you will pass on this idea. I know someone who works in the doc biz and is in contact with a lot of indie doc producers. I will pass the idea on to her.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by Archangel76, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By Archangel76
Member
3 months ago
2074 Posts
Re: Re: Bird with a Broken Wing (Crowd Source)
Posted By: Drifter
I strongly disagree with Repoman in this thread.
As someone who has published some seven hundred movie reviews at IMDb and written a screenplay myself, I can tell Repoman there is a difference between MovieMan's film and a horror story. That difference is ... genre.
A horror story is a work of fiction. The films by Dario Argento are rightly designated as "horror" films; they are all fiction.
"Bird With A Broken Wing" will not be a fictional story ... at least if the script doesn't veer too far from the facts as we know them.
The correct genre for MovieMan's film would be either film documentary, or drama, or thriller, or bio, possibly a combo of all four.
Where MovieMan gets his money is irrelevant. If horror fans want to contribute $ to MovieMan's project ... fine and dandy. Repoman, you must keep in mind the difficulty of making a film ... any film.
Hollywood studios routinely invest milliions of dollars on a film's production; and the result ... the movie bombs! But those studios have deep, deep pockets. They can afford to make flops. An individual cannot. The business of indie film production is daunting! For every indie film that gets released, there are hundreds or thousands that don't.
For these reasons, and for the publicity that "Bird With A Broken Wing" can generate for this criminal case, I'm more than willing to watch "Bird With A Broken Wing" and give it a positive recommendation at IMDb if it even remotely measures up to my standards. I have done that for other indie producers.
I think Repoman has gotten hung-up on the word "horror", and mistakingly assumed that "Bird With A Broken Wing" will be ... just another silly horror film directed at a juvenile audience.
Or maybe it was the fact the Cameron has crime scene photos of the victims bodies in the promo for this film. Maybe I took that the wrong way. Now that I know that Cameron doesn't even like horror films.....well you can imagine how foolish I feel.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by Repoman, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts
Drifter
How much can we put you down for? This Movie isn't going to make itself. If you donate enough you can get your name in the credits.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts
Re: Bird with a Broken Wing (Crowd Source)
I just want to say I DO NOT believe this is the place to solicit funds for your movie. I find it offensive and so do some victim's and their families. Cameron I have held my stance on this since day one and I know it seemed you took it to be an assassination of your character. It is not. I just feel there's a time and place for everything. In my opinion this is not the time or place. Nothing personal. I promise.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Profile Image
By guessting
Member
3 months ago
2030 Posts
Re: Drifter
Posted By: Repoman
How much can we put you down for? This Movie isn't going to make itself. If you donate enough you can get your name in the credits.
"...you can get your name in the credits".
----------------------------------------------
Oh please! I implied no such motivation.
Further, your critique is a put-down of anyone who contributes financial support to all indie films.
Edit
Flag
Quote
Quote
Edited by Drifter, 3 months ago
Profile Image
By Drifter
Member
3 months ago
371 Posts
Re: Re: Bird with a Broken Wing (Crowd Source)
Posted By: guessting
I just want to say I DO NOT believe this is the place to solicit funds for your movie. I find it offensive and so do some victim's and their families. Cameron I have held my stance on this since day one and I know it seemed you took it to be an assassination of your character. It is not. I just feel there's a time and place for everything. In my opinion this is not the time or place. Nothing personal. I promise.
Thanks guessting.
Flag
Quote
Quote
Profile Image
By Repoman
Member
3 months ago
1494 Posts