Post by Agent99 aka Sandia on Sept 14, 2013 17:20:11 GMT
Lepke, I agree that a potential list of students of male sixth-grade teachers should not be used to exclude people NOT on the list; but such a list would be very useful in excluding subjects ON the list.
The mere possibility that the writings were done by EAR/ONS make them very important and worth pursuing. Looking at students of male sixth-grade teachers in Visalia, Rancho Cordova, and Goleta would give you a reasonably manageable list of names to start checking out. Maybe EAR/ONS didn't write the essay; maybe he did, but grew up in another town -- it still has to checked out. Given the lack of other evidence to focus the search, the writings are a good lead that should not be ignored.
Here's another thought: suppose for the sake of argument that EAR/ONS did attend elementary school in Rancho Cordova. Even if he didn't write the essay, there is still a significant chance that he was a student of the Japanese-American sixth grade teacher, simply due to the limited number of schools in the area.
"D.S. devoted more than 43 years as an educator at Cordova Gardens Elementary School, Mitchell Jr. High School and Rancho Cordova Elementary School. He was the founder of a 5th and 6th grade summer camp at Redwood Glen in the Coastal Redwoods. He also developed a reading program at Mitchell Middle School for remedial students; was a facilitator for an intervention program at Cordova High School; developed both physical geography and cultural geography courses for the Sacramento County Office of Education. He also taught an all boys 6th grade class, bringing in an automobile engine for the boys to dismantle as a project, and was a "Tough Love" facilitator at Cordova High. D.S. was presented the Gold Award by the Capitol Service Center Council of the California Teachers Association in 1983, and the George Beck Award for Community Service in 1986 by the Folsom Cordova PTA Council. D.S. died on August 13, 2008.
Let the discussion continue.